17 September 2025

Interview questions: don't let casual chat lead to legal trouble

Interview questions: don't let casual chat lead to legal trouble

As an experienced HR consultant in Doncaster, I’ll talk you through common interview question pitfalls and how to protect your business from legal risks.

Why this matters for business owners

Finding the right people is essential for your business success. You want to ask questions that reveal skills, experience, and cultural fit. But in the effort to build rapport, it’s surprisingly easy to stray into risky territory.

Even well-intentioned small talk can open the door to discrimination claims, costing your business time, money, and unnecessary stress. This is where professional HR consultancy services in Doncaster can make all the difference. A compliant and fair recruitment process protects your business while helping you secure the best talent.

The hidden traps in interview questions

You want interviews to feel relaxed so candidates can perform at their best. But certain questions, even asked casually, fall under protected areas of law. If they don’t directly relate to the job, they should be avoided.

Keep the focus on what really matters: the candidate’s ability to do the role and contribute to your business goals.

Areas to avoid and safer alternatives

  • Family and children: Avoid questions about marital status, children, or family plans. Instead, ask about availability for the hours or travel the role requires.
  • Health or disability: You can ask if adjustments are needed for the interview or the role’s essential functions. Keep the focus on capability, not health status.
  • Spent convictions: Most roles don’t allow questions about spent convictions. Only raise this if the role is legally exempt, and always check current legislation.
  • Union membership: Questions about trade union involvement are strictly off-limits.
  • Age: Don’t ask directly or indirectly about age. Concentrate instead on skills, experience, and achievements.

Why these rules protect your business

These aren’t just legal technicalities. Following them helps you:

  • Reduce risk: Avoid costly discrimination claims and disputes.
  • Attract the best talent: A fair process appeals to a wider, more diverse pool of candidates.
  • Build a stronger team: Hiring based on merit creates more effective and balanced teams.
  • Protect your reputation: Demonstrating fairness shows your business is ethical and professional.

Practical steps to safeguard your recruitment

You can take simple, proactive steps to protect your business:

  • Review your questions: Keep interview questions job-focused and legally compliant.
  • Train your managers: Make sure everyone who interviews understands what can and can’t be asked.
  • Use structure: A consistent format for all candidates ensures fairness and focus.

How an HR consultant can help you hire with confidence

Employment law can feel complex, especially when you’re running a busy business. That’s where an outsourced HR consultant in Doncaster can give you peace of mind.

I can help by:

Ready to make your hiring bulletproof?

If you’d like to reduce risk and hire with confidence, let’s talk. As a local HR consultant in Doncaster, I support business owners with practical steps that protect their business and strengthen their teams.

Book a confidential call today and find out how HR consultancy services in Doncaster can give you clarity, consistency, and peace of mind in your recruitment.


HR consultant Doncaster

Reach Out

Whether you’re facing a difficult situation or just need some guidance and a friendly ear, we’re here to help. 

Fill out the form and one of our employment law experts will be in touch. Let’s start the conversation and find the support that’s right for you.

By submitting this form, you agree for a representative of Taurus HR and Employment Law to contact you.

Taurus HR Solutions Ltd are authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority for claims management activity.

Employees: You do not need to use a Claims Management firm (CMC) to make a claim, you can make a claim yourselves for free. You make the claim yourselves to your employer, or by submitting a grievance, or may wish to seek advice from ACAS or the Citizens Advice Bureau.

By using the services of a claims Management firm, it does not mean your claim will be resolved more quickly, or have a better prospect of success, or a better outcome, than if you were to make the claim yourselves for free.

Emergency Situation?

Workplace crisis? We are here when it matters the most.  We offer same-day HR and legal advice to help you take control quickly, with emergency support available out-of-hours. Whether you need to handle a gross misconduct incident quickly, manage a safeguarding concern or even secure last minute Employment Tribunal representation, we’ll give you clear, calm guidance and support right when you need it.

Call us now and speak directly with one of our employment law experts.

Open WhatsApp